Anuilla or Aruba in May?

My wife and I would like to go to one of the above 5/7-->5/14 for our
25th anniversery. I know Aruba has pretty consistent weather, but
Angilla has also interested us.

Any recommendations?

Thanks,
Jim

Thanks for all the info. Yes, we really want to bicycle the island.
Why do you say it is difficult, it only looks about 10 miles long and I
hear it is flat.

Anyway, I think we found a villa on Shoal Beach, so we are very
excited. Looks like we'll be going 4/30-5/7. Don't know about Saba
yet.

The flights are expensive (~$750), anybody got any pointers on getting
there cheaper from NH?

-Jim